Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant’s customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. By purchasing the products we rank, you’ll get the lowest price we found while we may receive a commission at no cost to you, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Advertising Disclosure
10 Best nostalgia premium ice creams of 2026
Explore top picks
1
GenericNostalgia Ice Cream Starter Pack - Maker Rock Salt (8lb) Bundled with Vanilla Creme, Chocolate, Strawberry and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Flavored Mix Packets (8oz each), 5 Piece Assortment
9.8Exceptional
Our Rating
-
-
Powerful technology We scan thousands of products and stores, analyzing reviews to find what matters most to users like you
Careful review Our team ensures quality, value, and fit based on real user feedback
Trusted insights AI and human analysis guide your decisions, reflecting real user prioritiesReal users impact
Thousands of users trust our site daily
- Based on millions of stores and reviews
- Shoppers influence our rankings
Analyzing top stores
2
NostalgiaNostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker - Old Fashioned Soft Serve Ice Cream Machine Makes Frozen Yogurt or Gelato in Minutes - Fun Kitchen Appliance - Vintage Wooden Style - Light Wood - 4 Quart
9.7Exceptional
Our Rating
-
3
Nani OrganicsIce Cream Mix. Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry. Each Pocket of 8 Oz Makes 2 Quarts of Delicious Premium Old Fashioned Ice Cream!
9.6Exceptional
-
4
Nani OrganicsIce Cream Mix. Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry. Each Pocket of 8 Oz Makes 2 Quarts of Delicious Premium Old Fashioned Ice Cream!
9.5Excellent
-
5
NostalgiaNostalgia ISK3 Premium Ice Cream Starter Kit
9.4Excellent
-
-
See Today’s Deals & Prices
6
NostalgiaNostalgia ICP825VAN8PK Premium Vanilla Creme Ice Cream Mix, 8 oz) Pack, Makes 16 quart Total
Key specs-
flavor:Premium Vanilla Crème
-
ingredients:Ice Cream Mix
-
package dimensions:5.75 x 11.5 x 6.75 inches
-
country of origin:N/A
-
serving size:N/A
9.2Excellent
Our Rating
-
7
NostalgiaNostalgia ICP825VAN8PK Premium Vanilla Creme Ice Cream Mix, 8 oz) Pack, Makes 16 quart Total
Key specs-
flavor:Premium Vanilla Crème
-
ingredients:Ice Cream Mix
-
package dimensions:5.75 x 11.5 x 6.75 inches
-
country of origin:N/A
-
serving size:N/A
9.0Excellent
Our Rating
-
8
NostalgiaNostalgia ICP825CHOC8PK Premium Chocolate Ice Cream Mix, 8 (8-Ounce) Packs, Makes 16 Quarts Total
8.9Very Good
-
9
NostalgiaNostalgia ICP825CHOC8PK Premium Chocolate Ice Cream Mix, 8 (8-Ounce) Packs, Makes 16 Quarts Total
8.8Very Good
-
10
NostalgiaNostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker - Old Fashioned Soft Serve Ice Cream Machine Makes Frozen Yogurt or Gelato in Minutes - Fun Kitchen Appliance - Modern Style - Tan - 1.5 Quart
8.6Very Good
Our Rating
-
